Noun clause

In English, when a full sentence serves as an object, we technically usually use the connector word "that." However, in casual English, we almost always delete it.

• Full Version: "I feel that he is a liar."
• Casual Version: "I feel he is a liar."

Unlike an adjective or a phrase, this group of words has its own internal grammar (Subject + Verb).

• Subject: He
• Verb: is
• Complement: a liar

Because it contains a Subject and a Verb, it is a Clause. Because the whole clause answers the question "What?" (like a noun), it is a Noun Clause.

To prove it is a Direct Object (and not a complement), you can replace the entire phrase with the word "it" or "this."

• Sentence: "I feel he is a liar."
• Test: "I feel it." (referring to a hunch) or "I feel this."

The rules for which tense to use inside that clause depend entirely on the Main Verb (the first verb). This concept is often called the Sequence of Tenses.

Here is the breakdown of the three main scenarios.

Scenario 1: The "Free Pass" (Main Verb is Present/Future)

If your main verb is in the Present (think, say, believe) or Future (will say), you have total freedom.

The Rule: Use whatever tense makes logical sense for the situation. You do not need to change anything.

• Main Verb: I believe (Present)...
  • Past Event: ...that he stole the money yesterday.
  • Current Event: ...that he is stealing the money right now.
  • Future Event: ...that he will steal the money tomorrow.

Why? Since your "believing" is happening right now, your perspective on time is normal.

---

Scenario 2: The "Backshift" (Main Verb is Past)

This is where grammar gets strict. If your main verb is in the Past (thought, said, knew), you usually must push the clause's tense one step back into the past.

The Rule: Move the inner verb one step backward in time.

**The Conversion Table**

Original Thought (Present)	Noun Clause (After Past Verb)
Present Simple "I like it."	Past Simple He said he liked it.
Present Continuous "I am working."	Past Continuous He said he was working.
Past Simple "I arrived."	Past Perfect He knew I had arrived.
Present Perfect "I have eaten."	Past Perfect He knew I had eaten.
Future (Will) "I will go."	Conditional (Would) He thought he would go.
Can / May	Could / Might He thought he could do it.

Nuance: Even if the situation is still true right now (e.g., "I knew she was angry"), we often use the past tense just to match the main verb. It sounds more harmonious.

---

Scenario 3: The "Fact" Exception (No Backshift)

There is one exception to Scenario 2. If the Noun Clause states a Universal Truth or a fact that is still definitely true, you do not have to backshift.

• General Truth:
  • Strict Grammar: Galileo proved that the earth moved around the sun.
  • Logic Exception: Galileo proved that the earth moves around the sun. (It still does).
• Current Reality:
  • "I told you yesterday that I am 30 years old." (I didn't turn 31 overnight, so "am" is fine).

---

Scenario 4: The "Subjunctive" Trap (Suggestion Verbs)

This is an advanced grammar point that trips up many learners.

If the main verb expresses a Suggestion, Demand, or Importance (e.g., suggest, recommend, demand, insist), you do NOT use time tenses. You use the Base Form (Bare Infinitive) of the verb.

This is called the Subjunctive Mood.

• Wrong: I suggest (that) he goes home. (Do not use "es/s").
• Wrong: I suggest (that) he went home. (Do not use past).
• Correct: I suggest (that) he go home. (Base form).
• Wrong: The doctor recommended that she eats less sugar.
• Correct: The doctor recommended that she eat less sugar.

Common Verbs for this rule:

• Suggest
• Recommend
• Insist
• Demand
• Request

**Summary Checklist**

1. Check the Main Verb: Is it Past Tense?
2. If No (Present/Future): Use any logical tense in the clause.
3. If Yes (Past): Backshift the clause (is -> was, will -> would, did -> had done).
4. Exceptions: Is it a scientific fact? (Keep present). Is it a suggestion? (Use base form).

Would you like to try a few "Backshift" conversions to see if you can spot the correct past form?

The reason there is no tense (no time) is that the action hasn't happened yet, and it might never happen.

When you use the Subjunctive Mood (e.g., "I demand that he be here"), you are entering the World of Ideas, not the World of Facts.

Here is the logic behind why we strip away the time.

1. The "Fact vs. Idea" Logic

English grammar is obsessed with reality.

• The Indicative Mood (Normal Grammar): This is for Facts. Facts happen at a specific time (Yesterday, Today, Tomorrow). Therefore, they need Tenses.
  • Fact: "He eats an apple." (He is doing it right now).
• The Subjunctive Mood: This is for Concepts. A suggestion, a demand, or a wish is just a "picture" of an action in your head. It has no time because it isn't real yet.
  • Idea: "I suggest that he eat an apple."
  • Logic: I am just pointing at the concept of "eating." I don't care when he does it, I just want the action to exist.

The easiest way to understand this structure is to imagine that there is an invisible modal verb (usually "should") that got deleted.

Remember that after "should," we always use the Base Form (Rule: No "to", no "-ed", no "-s").

• Step 1 (The Meaning): I insist that he (should) apologize.
• Step 2 (The Deletion): We remove "should" to make it faster/more formal.
• Step 3 (The Result): I insist that he apologize.

Note: In British English, they often keep the "should." In American English, we almost always delete it, leaving the "naked" verb behind.

3. The "Naked Verb" (The Base Form)

When we remove the tense, we are stripping the verb down to its purest form.

Think of tenses (the "-s" or "-ed" endings) as "clothing" that tells us when an action happened.

• "Plays": Wearing the "Present Tense" shirt.
• "Played": Wearing the "Past Tense" coat.
• "Play": The naked verb. It has no clothes because it hasn't stepped into the timeline yet.

Comparison Table

Type	Sentence	Why?
Indicative (Fact)	"I know that he is honest."	It is a fact. It exists right now. It needs a time marker ("is").
Subjunctive (Idea)	"I demand that he be honest."	It is not a fact yet. He might be lying right now! I am demanding the concept of honesty.

The "S" Trap

The place where this looks weirdest is with He/She/It. Your brain wants to put an "S" on the verb, but you must resist.

• Wrong: "I recommend that she studying." (Too much grammar).
• Wrong: "I recommend that she studies." (This sounds like a fact).
• Correct: "I recommend that she study." (The pure action).

Summary: There is no tense because a suggestion is timeless. It is just a blueprint of an action that you want to happen.